Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Patrick M's avatar

Gosh I love MCDC

Daniel Bush, PhD's avatar

I understand Campbell wanting to be cautious, but I question the logic of putting so much emphasis on practice reps. If Branch is medically cleared and physically ready, what exactly are we gaining by delaying his return? He already understands the defensive schemes, and he’s a better player than those currently filling his role.

There’s a risk of reinjury whether he’s practicing or playing. If he aggravates something in practice, the team gains nothing and loses him again. If he’s on the field Sunday, at least those reps have the potential to help the Lions win a football game.

Obviously, you don’t rush someone back before he’s medically ready. But once he is, I’d rather see him getting meaningful game reps than spending additional time proving in practice what we already know he can do. At some point, caution has to be weighed against the value of actually having your best players on the field.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?